Last year’s holiday campaigns revealed clear lessons for small senders. Experts in the field share what worked, what fell short, and what they would change. From audience segmentation to list preparation and email authentication, these insights can help make the next holiday season more effective.

  • Mail Only Engaged Contacts
  • Reawaken Lists by Early October
  • Define Segments Ahead of December
  • Secure Authentication Before Peak Traffic

Mail Only Engaged Contacts

1. Biggest Lesson?

Clients treat the holidays as a reason to mail everyone, constantly. Several send multiple emails a day to the whole list with no segmentation, and by the end of December none of it reaches the inbox. Gmail and Microsoft watch how people react, and a list ignoring five emails a day teaches them you're noise.

2. What Would You Do Differently?

Segment before the first send. Split by purchase history, interests and engagement. Someone who hasn't engaged in a year shouldn't get five emails a day about something they never cared about. Start with recent engagers and widen only if open rates hold.

3. What Underperformed?

Blasting the full list. A telehealth client with about 1 million contacts sent one campaign to roughly 700,000 people and got a 10.9% open rate. After we moved them to engaged segments of 27,000 to 72,000, sends opened at 70% to 82%. They reached more people with a sixth of the mail.

4. Deliverability or List-Quality Problems?

That same client went from a 164,000 monthly peak to 4.9 million sends in one month, and Gmail inbox placement fell to 0%. We cut volume, sent by engagement tier, and suppressed hard bounces, contacts inactive 120 days or more, and typo domains such as gmail.con. Opens went from 12.9% to over 70%.

5. How Do You Prep Your List?

Remove people who shouldn't get mail before anyone does: hard bounces, role addresses, misspelled domains and long-term inactives. Check recent sign-ups for bot patterns. Then segment by purchase, clicks and recency, and send to the most engaged group first.

6. #1 Tip for Small Senders?

Send to fewer people who still read you. A smaller engaged list beats a big one that ignores you, and Gmail and Microsoft agree. If a contact hasn't opened in a year, they've told you something.

Truitt Dill, Email Deliverability Consultant, Formula Inbox

Reawaken Lists by Early October

The biggest lesson I keep seeing is that the send calendar gets planned and the list doesn't. Volume jumps in November on a list that went quiet in August, and mailbox providers read that spike as suspicious.

This year I'd start warming the list in early October with ordinary useful emails, so the holiday sends land on people who've seen the sender's name recently.

The tactic that underperforms most often is the one discount blast to everyone. It trains people to wait for the coupon and pushes unsubscribes up. Segmenting by who opened or bought recently does more than any subject line trick.

The usual deliverability trouble is old addresses and junk sign-ups from popups and contest forms. The fix is a verification pass on anything that's been sitting for months, a confirm step on popup forms, and pulling hard bounces out before the send.

Before a big send I verify the list, drop the people who haven't opened in half a year, and check SPF and DKIM. Then I send a small batch first and watch bounce and complaint rates. If that batch looks off, the full send waits.

My top tip for small senders is a short automated follow-up to people who clicked but didn't buy. Nucleus Research ties marketing automation to 451% more qualified leads, and that follow-up is where a small list earns most of its money.

Victor Smushkevich Profile Founder, Tested Media

Define Segments Ahead of December

The holidays are not one audience, and that is the lesson that stuck. We sell through service providers and resellers, so that group is winding down in December while the businesses they serve are still buying. We sent to the whole list on one schedule, and that schedule only suited part of it.

What I would do differently is decide the segments before the season starts. We spent a stretch last year pulling our sequences and automation into one place, and the real gain was not the automation. It was being made to say who was on the list and why they were there.

I would also stop assuming people know what we do. When the product sits in a specific niche, a lot of a list has never met the category, so a December offer reaches someone who needed the explanation first. Send the explanation in November.

For a small sender, hold December to a couple of sends and put the effort into January, when the buying conversations restart.

Dora Bloom, Chief Revenue Officer, iotum

Secure Authentication Before Peak Traffic

The biggest lesson from last year's holiday campaigns is that volume spikes without strict authentication land straight in the spam folder. Mailbox providers heavily monitor sudden traffic jumps, meaning any lingering gaps in SPF, DKIM, or DMARC immediately trigger bounces or junk placement.

What small senders need to do differently is automate domain authentication before the shopping season begins. Blasting dormant segments during peak retail weeks while scrambling to troubleshoot manual DNS records ruins sender reputation when you need it most.

My top tip: lock down your authentication records early, maintain tight list hygiene, and don't try to re-engage lapsed contacts during high-stakes holiday pushes.

Al Iverson, Industry Research and Community Engagement Lead, ValiMail

Final Takeaways for Your Next Holiday Campaign

The experiences shared by these experts point to a common lesson: successful holiday email campaigns depend on preparation, audience segmentation, and consistent list management. Start by identifying engaged contacts, reviewing your existing list, and defining audience segments before the holiday season begins. Prepare your sending infrastructure and check domain authentication before increasing campaign volume.

List quality deserves equal attention. Remove hard bounces, outdated contacts, invalid addresses, and long-term inactive subscribers before your holiday sends. Reviewing older email addresses with an email verification tool helps identify invalid contacts and reduce avoidable bounce risks before launching a campaign.

For small senders, the priority is to maintain a healthy email list, reach the right audience, and prepare their email infrastructure ahead of peak holiday traffic. Addressing these areas before the holiday season gives your campaigns a stronger foundation for consistent email deliverability.